Monday, 8 June 2015

Just 2-6 weeks, it is not a STRICT diet for life

By Dr Jaci Barrett (Dietitian, Lecturer) & Caroline Tuck (Dietitian, PhD Candidate)

We hope this post gives you a better understanding & awareness on WHY the low FODMAP diet is not a strict diet for life.


With the growing interest and success of the low FODMAP diet, the diet is being taken up by thousands of people internationally. This is great news - finally a strategy to improve symptoms for the majority with IBS!

As with anything there is a downside… The rapid uptake of the diet, which for many does not include guidance from an experienced dietitian, has led to a vast number of people following a strict low FODMAP diet long term. We are seeing more and more of this now as we are getting involved in social media. This strict compliance is due to:
  1.  Fear of symptoms returning if you eat high FODMAP foods
  2. Confusion over the misinformation on the internet regarding which foods are safe
  3. Belief that it is a diet for life; and, in most cases
  4.  All of the above
The truth is the low FODMAP diet is designed to be followed strictly for an initial 2-6 weeks until symptoms resolve. At that stage, gentle reintroductions are encouraged by your dietitian to learn your level of tolerance.



What does it mean exactly to “re-introduce”?
The aim during this phase is:
  • To see if any moderate-to-high FODMAP food can be re-introduced AND
  • For the patient to continue to have good symptom control. 
This is where the re-introduction phase is very individualised and will depend on how severe your symptoms are, what type of symptoms you experienced (e.g. constipation or bloating or diarrhoea may have different trigger FODMAPs), and what your normal dietary habits are.
Some patients may be able to re-introduce many types of high FODMAP foods and eat them regularly. Other patients may only be able to re-introduce a couple of specific foods and only consume small amounts.
The re-introduction phase is about trying to find a GOOD BALANCE - between continuing to have good symptom control AND re-introduction of some higher FODMAP foods if possible in the amounts tolerated to have the beneficial prebiotic effects.
If you have not tried to reintroduce before, or have had trouble tolerating reintroductions - then it may be beneficial to speak with a Dietitian who specializes in the area, as they will be able to help you to do it in a strategic way and will adjust the re-introductions to suit your needs and your symptom types.  


Why is this important?
Relaxation of FODMAP restrictions is very important for several reasons. Firstly, it ensures patients include a varied diet, incorporating a wide range of foods rich in nutrients for optimal health. Secondly, research has demonstrated that FODMAPs are prebiotics. This means they are a food source for bacteria, encouraging the growth of good bacteria with potential health benefits.


The research
As many of you are aware, the low FODMAP diet has been developed over the past 10 years through research that our department has been conducting, and has now also been found to be effective by other research groups around the world. As the dietary research has progressed the diet-itself has undergone refinement and so we continue to make further adjustments to our recommendations. 
In the past two years, there have been two important research studies (one from the group in King's College London (KCL), one from here at Monash University [1, 2]), which have not just looked at symptom improvement on the Low FODMAP diet, but have started to look beyond symptom control and assessed possible changes to the gut microbiota.  [One of the major reasons for our interest in this was the well established knowledge that that 2 major FODMAP( namely fructans and GOS) are also well known prebiotic carbohydrates -that is,  they help the growth of good bacteria in the large intestine)].   Both the KCL and Monash studies found that individuals who stay on the low FODMAP diet develop changes in their gut microbiota.  

In other words, to summarise:
  1. 2 major FODMAP (Fructans & GOS) help the growth of good bacteria in our large intestine
  2. These studies have shown that by adhering to a strict low FODMAP diet, levels of some of our good bacteria fall
  3. We reduce FODMAPs to improve IBS symptoms because they are fermented and produce gas
  4. BUT we need them in the diet long term to obtain the right balance of gut bacteria.
While this is a very new area of research - and we do not fully understand the implications of these types of changes -  we do feel that it is best to advise people that a very strict low FODMAP diet should not be followed over the long-term.




So now what?
Now that we know that these changes may occur, Monash is much more pro-active in encouraging patients who are on the diet, to try and re-introduce some high FODMAP foods if they are able to tolerate it. Everyone is different and so you will have to discover your own 'tolerance level'. It is certainly worth trying and it has been our experience that MANY individuals end up with much less restrictive diets and with only a few key foods they avoid.

PLEASE INCLUDE SOME FODMAPS IN YOUR DIET & SPREAD THE WORD!

Any suggestions of how to begin?
A good place to start is with canned legumes such as chickpeas or 4 bean mix. These contain only small levels of prebiotic galacto-oligosaccharides – small enough to not cause significant symptoms, but sufficient to gradually build your prebiotic intake and encourage good bacterial growth. Alternatively pick one of your favourite foods that you couldn't eat whilst on the diet & try eating a small amount.
If you are hesitant, please seek the advice of an experienced dietitian to help guide you through the process.


Will I ever be able to eat normally again?
Often patients who have completed the reintroduction phase, unfortunately do not end up eating exactly as they did before the low FODMAP diet, but they might be on their own modified version of the low FODMAP diet. I.e. they may still follow parts of the diet that they need to in order to continue to have good symptom control, but re-introduce some high FODMAP foods that they are able to tolerate.
It is also important to remember that with IBS, the symptoms DO NOT ALWAYS stay the same. This means that even if you find that you are not able to reintroduce much right now due to symptoms - you may find in 3, 6 or 12 months time, that your symptoms have improved and you are able to tolerate more. 
Again we recommend that you work with you dietitian to slowly re-introduce some higher FODMAP foods into your diet.  


Other suggested readings:
Click here if you would also like to read a older blog post written by us that also briefly talks about the Low FOMAP diet being not a 'lifetime' diet.


References:
  1. Staudacher, H.M., et al., Fermentable Carbohydrate Restriction Reduces Luminal Bifidobacteria and Gastrointestinal Symptoms in Patients with Irritable Bowel Syndrome. The Journal of Nutrition, 2012. 142(8): p. 1510-1518.
  2. Halmos, E.P., et al., Diets that differ in their FODMAP content alter the colonic luminal microenvironment. Gut, 2015. 64(1): p. 93-100.

12 comments:

  1. Hi just wondering why fresh Mango is high in fructose and dried high in Fructans?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is a good question. We believe that the processing e.g.heating, drying etc. of fruits may alter the structure or composition of carbohydrates in foods such as in mango. It is an interesting area that deserves further investigation into how food processing may alter FODMAP content of foods.
      Kindly, CK

      Delete
  2. Hi
    I've just started the elimination phase and I'm wondering about serving sizes. Say for lettuce..1cup is low fodmap so can I have more than 1 cup or do I need to stick to the serving sizes? Also does this mean measuring everything for the stage of the diet? Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi,

      With lettuce, you can eat freely as there is a negligible amount of FODMAPs. I would recommend reading our blog post on serving sizes:

      http://fodmapmonash.blogspot.com/search?q=serving+size

      Hope this answers some of your questions. Good luck on the elimination phase.

      Delete
    2. Thank you...so if it doesn't say we can't eat more than a certain amount I can take it that I can eat as much as I want? Such as lettuce, carrot, cucumber?

      Delete
  3. Thanks for the blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for.
    Diet

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have just started the challenge phase. Does the entire portion need to be eaten in one meal (eg 1.5 mangoes on day 3! ) or can it be spread throughout the day?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have just started the challenge phase. Does the entire challenge portion need to be eaten in one meal (eg 1.5 mangoes in day 3!) or can it be spread throughout the day?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thankyou for your help I was just wondering in the 2nd phase reintroduction is that 3 months or 8 weeks as I had spent 8 weeks on lowfod map, reintroducing fibre worries me, but then constipation is a big problem, so could you recommend a fibre supplement, as I had some benefibre and have bad.bbpsins now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Beth, please see this post for more information about suitable fibre sources and supplements: http://bit.ly/2cCwv1Y

      Best wishes, The Monash FODMAP team

      Delete
  7. Thank you for this post , I am 3 years on the FODMAP diet now - shocking I know after reading the article. I'm definitely afraid to reintroduce foods...

    ReplyDelete
  8. But it has been the Korean's experience that Koreans eat at home more frequently. 2 Week Diet Plan

    ReplyDelete